Cash Buyer vs Agent in Tennessee
What each option costs, how long it takes and what you'd walk away with, including when listing is the better call.
Get Your Free Cash Offer
Takes less than 60 seconds. No obligation.
🔒 Your info is private and never shared.
The Short Answer
Should You Sell for Cash or List With an Agent?
If your house is in good shape and you can wait a few months, listing with an agent will usually put more money in your pocket. If it needs major repairs, you're on a deadline, or you can't keep paying for it while it sits, a cash sale often comes out close or ahead once every cost is counted. Compare what you'd walk away with, not the sale price.
Tennessee Cash For Homes buys houses for cash, so you know where we stand. We still tell people to list when that's the better move, and one of those sellers said so in a review.
The difference comes down to who's buying. A retail buyer is usually a family with a mortgage, so the sale depends on their loan, an inspection and an appraisal. We pay cash, so none of that applies.
Once a listing has an accepted offer, the house still has to clear the buyer's inspection, a round of repair requests, the lender's appraisal and final loan approval. That stretch is where most deals slip, and it's a big reason sellers call us: not every house, or every moving date, can ride out weeks of renegotiating.
That includes dated, damaged, inherited and vacant houses, and rentals with tenants still living in them. We buy in Columbia, Spring Hill, Franklin, Murfreesboro, Nashville and the towns around them. See every city and county on our where we buy page.
Side by Side
Cash Buyer vs Agent: How the Two Options Compare
Green marks the better option on each factor. Red marks the drawback.
| Factor | Tennessee Cash For HomesClose in 7 to 30 days | Listing With an Agent |
|---|---|---|
| Sale price | Drawback: Lower price Priced for repairs and risk | Advantage: Higher price Best for move-in ready homes |
| Agent commission | Advantage: No commission | Drawback: You pay commission Negotiable, often the biggest cost |
| Other fees and closing costs | Advantage: We pay them all No fees on top | Drawback: You pay your share Plus any repair credits you agree to |
| Repairs | Advantage: No repairs Bought as-is, any condition | Drawback: Often required Before listing and after inspection |
| Showings | Advantage: One walkthrough | Drawback: Many showings Plus photos and open houses |
| Timeline | Advantage: 7 to 30 days You pick the closing date | Drawback: Often months Market time plus loan closing |
| Certainty | Advantage: No financing risk No loan, no appraisal | Drawback: Can fall through Financing, appraisal, or inspection |
| Typical net proceeds | Lower price, no costs taken out | Higher price, many costs taken out |
Your mortgage payoff and any liens come out of the sale either way.
Where the Money Goes
What Listing With an Agent Costs You
A good agent earns their fee: pricing from real sales, MLS exposure (the MLS is the shared database of homes for sale that agents search) and negotiating. On the right house that brings a higher price. Here's what comes out of it before you see a check.
Commission
Negotiable, and no Tennessee law sets the rate. Since August 2024, what you pay a buyer's agent is negotiated separately instead of posted on the MLS.
Repairs
Paint, cleaning and small fixes so the house shows well. A bad roof or a dead HVAC system can hold up a buyer's loan until it's fixed.
Repair credits
After the inspection, buyers usually ask for repairs or a credit at closing. It comes off after the price feels settled.
Closing costs
Your share of closing costs, plus your payoff and prorated taxes (this year's property taxes up to the day you close). Tennessee's transfer tax falls on the buyer by statute (TCA 67-4-409).
Holding costs
Mortgage, taxes, insurance and utilities keep running every month the house sits. None of it shows on the settlement statement.
Same either way
Tennessee's disclosure law (TCA 66-5-201 and following) applies with or without an agent. Our closing costs guide has the full list of seller costs.
What We Take Off the Price Instead
What our price covers
The repairs, the months we carry the house while we fix it, the cost of reselling it and the risk. Here's how cash buyers calculate an offer.
What you get back
Speed and certainty. With no lender, a loan denial or a low appraisal can't sink the deal late. You do give up the chance of a bidding war.
What we pay
All closing costs, with no fees and no commission. We buy as-is and can close in as little as 7 days, about 30 typical. See how it works.
What about selling it yourself?
Selling by owner (FSBO) saves the listing agent's commission, but you take on the pricing, marketing, showings, disclosure form and contract yourself. If you're weighing it, start with our guide to selling by owner in Tennessee, or read how to sell without a realtor in Nashville.
Which One Fits
When Each Option Is the Better Choice
Listing with an agent is usually better when
- The house is move-in ready, with no major roof, foundation or system problems.
- Similar homes near you sell quickly to buyers using mortgages.
- You have a few months and can cover the payments while it's listed.
- You want the top price and don't mind showings and negotiating.
- The title is clean, with no liens, estate questions or tenants.
“…he was so honest to tell us that in our particular case, it would make more sense to sell with a traditional agent. He set us up with Chris, who we really like, and decided to go that route.”
In a hot market with multiple offers, listing tends to win by more.
Listing guides: get the most money · how long it takes
A cash sale usually makes more sense when
- The house needs repairs you can't afford or don't want to manage.
- You need to close by a certain date.
- You're carrying two payments, or the house is inherited or vacant.
- There are tenants in place.
- A listing already fell through or isn't getting the price you need.
“An elderly Columbia homeowner had lost her husband, and the house needed more repairs than she could afford. We worked closely with her son, handled the title still being in her late husband's name, and closed in about a month, as-is.”
In a slow market, or when time matters more than price, cash tends to win.
We buy in Nashville · Murfreesboro · Clarksville · all areas
Get Both Numbers in Writing
-
Get an agent's net sheet A net sheet is an agent's written estimate of what you'd take home after commission, closing costs and repairs. Ask two or three agents with a track record in your area.
-
Get a written cash offer Make sure it says who pays closing costs and lists any fees or contingencies (conditions that let the buyer back out). Check the buyer's reviews.
-
Compare what you'd walk away with Put the two numbers side by side and go with what you keep, not the bigger sale price.
Ready for step 2? Get a written cash offer →
Related guides
This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. For an estate, divorce or tax question, talk to a Tennessee attorney or CPA.
Why Homeowners Choose Tennessee Cash For Homes
When you call, you talk to us, not a call center or an out-of-state company. We have been buying houses in Maury County for 7+ years and have bought over 100 homes there. We are a Middle Tennessee family owned business that believes in doing business the right way.
- Based right here in Middle Tennessee
- Family owned and relationship focused
- Fair, straightforward cash offers
- No cleaning, no repairs, no hidden fees
- Flexible closing on your timeline
Common Questions